Would you enjoy being stuck in jail, with no way to get out, and without being officially convicted? For a year, two years, even three years of your life that you can never get back? Would you enjoy knowing, that despite all of the effort our founding fathers put into making a fair court system, the government is not seeing you as “innocent until proven guilty.” What’s even worse is that this is happening in, “the land of the ‘free’.”
New Jersey politicians are trying to pass an amendment to “allow courts to order pretrial detention to a person in a criminal case.” They want to keep people safe, but in the process they violate the 5th Amendment to the US Constitution. The amendment states, “No person shall…nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property without due process of law.”
This means that it is illegal to keep a person in jail without bail before he or she is convicted by a jury. Pretrial detention does just that. It deprives a person of his or her liberty, slowly ruining their spirit, their reputation, and their chance at success, without due process of law.
On top of that this amendment is very vague. It allows courts to order pretrial detention to “dangerous individuals” who are considered a “threat to society.” Yet both of these terms are left undefined…
English Jurist William Blackstone once said, “It is better that ten guilty persons escape than one innocent suffer.” America has executed innocent people, whose innocence was only proven after they died. What price must we pay to keep our posterity both free and safe? Is safety more important than freedom? Maybe one day we will know, but today isn’t that day.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI thought this blog was very well done and very understandable especially for ones that have little to no knowledge about Pre-Trail dentition. Matt especially stated was it feels like to be in jail when he states: "Would you enjoy being stuck in jail, with no way to get out, and without being officially convicted? For a year, two years, even three years of your life that you can never get back?" These questions draw pictures in ones mind about the setting of jail, process of being convicted and most of all clearly states what Pre-Trial detention is in just 2 sentences. In addition, when Matt took the quote from William Blackstone, “It is better that ten guilty persons escape than one innocent suffer.” It was very much put suspense and most of all makes people think about innocent individuals. It was very important to explain Pre-Trail detention in the best way possible and Matt did a very good job go doing so. With asking questions to make things more suspenseful and stating a real quote really brought the whole piece together as a whole.Bravo Matt!!
ReplyDeleteThis would really explain to those who don't know what pretrial detention is. You expanded on the definition of pretrial detention and made me see examples in my head. I love the quote and the reference to the land of the free and innocent until proven guilty. This blog was done very well and i loved it. Good job Matt.
ReplyDelete